I have to be pretty excited about a new song idea to summon the energy to make it as good as it can be, which can take a lot of work and time. Unfortunately, this doesn’t guarantee it’ll be a good song.
But that’s OK. I’ll explain.
I need enthusiasm to get going. I need to think I’ve really got something. I can’t question it too much. If I start doubting myself or my song too early on I’ll never know how good it could’ve been. I’ve got to follow through and take it as far as I can.
It’s only later that I find out if my song is bad, mediocre, average, good, or better than that. I have to play it for an audience, friends, in a performance or a recording. Only in this way, when it’s (more or less) done, will both the flaws and the strengths of the song be revealed.
When writing, it’s all about forward motion and momentum. It’s NOT (at first) about second-guessing. That voice in my head always ready to pipe in with, ‘this sucks!’ has to be ignored, at least until I get into the rewriting.
There’s no way to predict ahead of time the value and quality of a song. And that’s not even the point. Some of my songs will be bad, some will be indifferent. But those have to be written to get to the good ones.
Let me know your thoughts, additions, disagreements in the Comments section below:

And please share on facebook etc. by clicking the tabs below –