Site Loader
New York, NY

Have you ever tried writing a song with just one chord? This is an assignment I give occasionally in songwriting workshops and the results, particularly given how limited the idea can seem at first, are often really good.

Lacking harmonic variety, successful one-chord songs seem to put a strong emphasis on the groove of the song, the notes and rhythm of the melody, the lyric, and the performance. And they can benefit from that emphasis.

There are a lot of songs that I’d call almost one-chord songs, such as The Who’s ‘Magic Bus’ (Peter Townshend), War’s ‘Cisco Kid’, Harry Nillson’s ‘Jump Into The Fire’, Talking Heads’ ‘Once In A Lifetime (TH w. Brian Eno), Creedence Clearwater Revival’s ‘Born On The Bayou’ (John Fogerty), Sly & The Family Stone’s ‘Everyday People’ (Sylvester Stewart), The Beatles’ ‘Tomorrow Never Knows’ (Lennon/McCartney). Some great songs, but I’d say they, in various different ways, introduce enough of the tonality of a second chord to fall outside the category.

In songwriting history, there aren’t all that many that truly stick to one chord, but the good ones are strong.

To begin with, there’s a long tradition of one-chord blues songs. Some of the most famous are ‘Spoonful’ (Willie Dixon), ‘I’m A Man’ (Muddy Waters), ‘Who Do You Love’ (Bo Diddley), and ‘Smokestack Lightning’ (Howlin’ Wolf). A lot of even earlier country blues songs have only one chord (if that!). Most Mississippi Hill Country blues, most notably by R.L. Burnside, are the same – for example, Porkchop Willie’s ‘Too Many Cuts’ (Bill Hammer).

There are some classic one-chord R&B songs – Aretha Franklin’s ‘Chain Of Fools’ (Don Covay), Wilson Pickett’s ‘Land Of A Thousand Dances’ (Chris Kenner), and ‘Funky Broadway’ (Arlester ‘Dyke’ Christian), Jr. Walker’s ‘Shotgun’ (Autry DeWalt) and, later, Sly’s ‘Thank You’ (Sylvester Stewart). Also occasional Pop songs, like Sonny & Cher’s ‘The Beat Goes On’ (by Sonny Bono – and Donovan’s ‘The Trip’, on which it’s based); Rock songs like The Guess Who’s (and now Lenny Kravitz’s) ’American Woman, Creedence Clearwater Revival’s ‘Run Through The Jungle’; and the incredible and uncategorizable ‘Coconut’ by Harry Nillson.

More recent and contrasting entrants into the one chord sweepstakes are Pink’s ‘Get The Party Started’ (Linda Perry) and I Am Snow Angel’s ‘Losing Face’ (Julie Kathryn).

One thing these songs seem to have in common is a lot of drive. I wouldn’t exactly say they’re compensating for a lack of chords, but their power and interest have to come from somewhere else – and they do.

There are quite a few good role models above. If you haven’t written one yet… why not try?

Can you add any songs I’ve missed to the ones listed above? Or would you subtract any?

Let me know your thoughts in the Comments section below:

pink-getthepartystarted

And please share on facebook etc. by clicking the tabs below the videos –

Share this page on:

0Shares

15 Comments on “Can You Write A One-Chord Song?”

  1. Good post, Tony, and timely for me, so thanks! I was just working on a one-chord song yesterday. It’s a challenge for sure (and, admittedly I’m cheating as I introduce a chord change for the last six bars) but your examples are great. I’m trying to think of an effective example that’s more of a dirge, like U2’s (two-chord) MLK, but am coming up dry right now. That’s the feel I’m operating in and your piece has got me thinking more about the rhythm of the melody and that can only help.

  2. Well yes, of course it’s possible, I’ve been called upon to do it a number of times as an academic exercise, some more successfully than others. One thing they all had in common was that at some point they all wanted to use a different chord, and sticking to the one-chord restriction seemed like second best. As you mentioned, somewhere along the way each melody implied a chord change by using a note outside the core triad. Singing a B over A minor, for example. In general, using “one chord” as a starting point places too many obstacles in the way of writing a good melody. God knows it’s hard enough to do that with a full palette of chords.

    1. Thanks for your comments, Pete.
      I will say that in any melody I’d hate to have to stick only to the chord tones, or to have to change chords every time I went outside them. Almost every melody, no matter the amount of chords, employs non-chord notes.
      Best wishes,
      Tony

  3. playing and singing a pentatonic oriented melody over a typical R&B extended (9th or 11th chord) doesn’t seem that big a stretch…..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *